For those who think this era was immune to political controversy and accusations, think again. It was then that ‘we stuffed ballot boxes,’ because this disease needed a strong remedy.”, Tillman added: “I do not ask anybody to apologize for it. This gave him the lead by a single, and controversial, electoral vote (185-184). For a country that was still in the reconstruction process, this wasn’t a good thing. He was also the national commander of the Military Order of the Loyal Legion. They awarded all of the states — a total of 20 electoral votes — to Hayes by an 8-to-7 vote. I love your overviews of all the presidents. Many believe Republicans made a deal to appease Southern Democrats in a secret meeting at Washington’s Wormley’s Hotel, which was owned by African American James Wormley. Sarah Tew/CNET Time is nearly up for the IRS and US Treasury to send the second stimulus checks. . Republican President Ulysses S. Grant had already sent federal troops to the states to help keep the peace. The place was nearly deserted. Elections Project, we are on track to see the highest voter turnout for a presidential election … Of course, none of those is to mention the 537-vote margin that George W. Bush won Florida by in the 2000 presidential election — out of almost 6 million votes cast — … For many, receiving a second stimulus check before Jan. 15 will be a race against time. Since the Civil War began, only Republicans had been elected to office. The third assumption was that the electors—at least following the completely predictable (and unanimous) election of George Washington as our first president—would quite often fail to reach majority approval of a specific candidate; in that case, according to the original Constitution, the decision would be made by the House of Representatives, with each state’s delegation having one vote. However, the election was riddled with voter fraud and suppression in the post-Civil War south. He also vowed to only serve a single term. If you want to get a head start on learning about next week’s president, join me in reading it! He became known as “His Fraudulency." Rutherford B. Hayes promised to run things differently than Grant. It was then that we shot them. “With your state sure for Hayes, he is elected. the Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library and Museums at Spiegel Grove, The Centennial President with the Icy Personality. (AP) — Vice President-elect Kamala Harris will resign her Senate seat on Monday, two days before she and President-elect Joe Biden are inaugurated. His election was so controversial because not only did he not win the popular vote, but he also won by only one electoral vote. On March 5, there was a public inauguration ceremony. Unfortunately for Hayes, Democrats had the majority in Congress. Economists Casey B. Mulligan and Charles G. Hunter concluded in a 2001 study that only one of every 100,000 votes cast in federal elections, and one of every 15,000 votes cast in state legislative elections “mattered in the sense that they were cast for a candidate that officially tied or won by one vote.” Tilden continued to maintain “the country knows that I was legally elected president.” Dissidents dubbed Hayes “His Fraudulency.”. Live 2020 Presidential election results and maps by state. In South Carolina, despite voter suppression, the official turnout was 101 percent of eligible voters. The only presidents in US history that managed to win their elections unanimously, by winning all electoral spots were George Washington and James Monroe. Hayes traveled all over the U.S. during his presidency and was the first president to visit the West Coast. Top Answer. They commissioned portraits of some of the Founding Fathers and other early presidents. He won that race. Through some politicking, John Quincy Adams won the vote. As the days passed, the uncertainty increased. Live 2020 Presidential election results and maps by state. Hayes was also a huge supporter of African-American rights and became a champion for their education. But the process wasn’t over yet. Many historians speculate that a “backroom” deal was eventually made by Hayes to push it through. On Election Day in Edgefield, S.C., more than 300 armed Red Shirts on horseback “packed their horses so closely together that the only approach to the windows, back of which was the ballot box, was under the bellies of the beasts,” the Times said. James Garfield. Samuel J. Tilden a large lead. The problem was that the commission was made up of eight Republicans and seven democrats. On March 3, Grant hosted Hayes at the White House, where he was sworn in as president by the chief justice. Even though he had some celebrity campaigners (like Mark Twain) on his side, Hayes didn’t think he could win. Thanks for the education . So, instead of being sworn in on the steps of the U.S. Capitol, Hayes took the oath in the Red Room of the White House. How many other presidents have served one term? By signing up you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, Southern Whites were rebelling against Black political power. Not every election is won by popular vote, as was the case with President Rutherford B. Hayes and his election. Asked by Wiki User. Can you see why it was controversial? The rights of Black citizens in the South were devastated as a result. Destiny of a Republic: A Tale of Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a President is the most fascinating book. About midnight on his way home from a play in New York City on Election Day in 1876, Daniel Sickles stopped by Republican national headquarters at the Fifth Avenue Hotel. But the number clearly was inflated. Rutherford B. Hayes had a somewhat hard childhood. Amid cries of “Tilden or blood,” one Washington newspaper reported on plans “to send a threatening and bellicose mob to the National Capital to see that the count is made according to their wishes.”. It’s said after Lucy died, Fanny became her father’s constant companion. I don’t even start writing these “president of the week” posts anymore until after I’ve listened to it. The “Red Shirts” killed six Black men in the Hamburg massacre. As now, Republicans controlled the Senate, and Democrats controlled the House. To follow him up, Americans needed someone bold: enter Ulysses S. Grant, the hero of the Union. Andrew Johnson, who took over for Abraham Lincoln, had a disastrous presidency. 1964 : Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson got 486 electoral votes against Republican Barry M. Goldwater, … Congress blocked every thing he tried to submit for civil rights and giving black Americans the right to vote. Rutherford B. Hayes’ episode is just as fascinating as all the others. In 1876, ONE VOTE changed France from a monarchy to a republic. American politician John Quincy Adams … The vice president and Democratic candidate Al Gore got 50,999,000 votes nationally and beat the Republican candidate George W. Bush by 545,000 votes (0.5%). After heated debate, at 4:10 a.m. the president of the Senate formally announced that Hayes had been elected the 19th president by an electoral college vote of 185 to 184. Since Hayes couldn’t get much done with civil rights, he moved onto something he could do: civil service reform. In addition, the Washington Post has the BEST podcast titled Presidential. “I think we are defeated in spite of the recent good news,” he said. The President-Elect of the US is the candidate who receives … How interesting! The U.S. Presidential Election Process. They only had one daughter, named Fanny after Rutherford’s sister. The History Channel put together a mini-documentary on each president and they’re fascinating. In 1868, ONE VOTE saved President Andrew Johnson from impeachment. He served as a major, but was promoted to colonel and eventually major general. He didn’t take his seat until the war ended over seven months later. Which president won a presidential election by one vote? No one is entirely sure what this compromise consisted of but there are guesses. Here’s the longer (more expensive version) and here’s the shorter version. At that point, Hayes was already on his way to Washington when he heard the news. Four months after the bitterly contested election in 1876, Republican Rutherford B. Hayes emerged with a one-vote victory in the Electoral College. New York Governor Samuel Tilden was his opponent. ET, Biden had … In the four contested states, Republican and Democratic officials filed separate tallies for Hayes or Tilden, throwing the election into chaos. His chances were slim and he knew it. Despite that, the war proved to be a bright spot in his life. Apparently he was raised in a super strict, quite overprotected environment. Data reported as of 10 a.m., using information from The Associated Press It refers to her refusing to serve alcohol at the White House. All three of the disputed states electoral votes were given to Rutherford B. Hayes. Former White House and Capitol Hill staffer, wife, and mom. View Georgia’s 2020 election results for US President, ... two of five electoral votes go to the winner of the statewide vote. Data reported as of 10 a.m., using information from The Associated Press The soldiers loved him and so did those from his home state. Many democrats were so angry that they threatened to filibuster it. The Ulysses S. Grant Administration was infamous for hiring family and friends. The House of Representatives still had to confirm it. It was then that we killed them. “We set up the Democratic Party with one plank only, that this is White man’s country, and White men must govern it,” Tillman said. Rutherford B. Hayes (1876) Similar to 1824, the election of 1876 wasn’t decided by the voters, but … So how did such a man get his name in the hat for the presidency? Joe Biden won these two Massachusetts towns by just one vote, according to preliminary results. IT is customary for any sitting president in the US that is not re-elected to accept defeat and concede power to their opponent. Joe Biden won these two Massachusetts towns by just one vote, according to preliminary results. Apparently their campaign against each other was called “The Last Battle of the Civil War.” In a nutshell, on election night Tilden was several thousand votes ahead (a lot in those days). In his inauguration speech, Hayes said the time had come to allow the Southern states to govern themselves again. Gore won the popular vote by more than 500,000 votes but at the end of the Election Day, the count in Florida—the state that proved an Electoral College tipping point—was too close to call. I need to go back to review your older posts! Hayes also served as president of the Ohio State Archaeological and Historical Society, Ohio. House Democrats began a filibuster. The podcasts are that insightful into the character of these great men! Daniel Chamberlain. Tilden won 184 electoral votes — one shy of the number needed to win — to Hayes’ 165 votes. This all happened two days before the Inauguration. Thus began the longest fought and closest presidential election in U.S. history. Sickles, a former Union general, noticed something about the early returns, which gave Democratic New York Gov. Some came close, but none succeeded. He made it well known that he would never appoint anyone with connections to his family. The next day, Democratic newspapers trumpeted a Tilden victory. In 1923, ONE VOTE gave Adolf Hitler leadership of the Nazi Party. How did our president of the week, Rutherford B. Hayes, come out on top? We’ll answer these questions and more. All eyes focused on charges of intimidation of Black Republican voters in the three disputed Southern states (In Oregon, the issue was a disputed elector). This left his mother alone with a baby and a young daughter (named Fanny). Hayes had 165 votes. Explain to your children why the Electoral College was set up and that with most things established by our Founding Fathers, compromise was the key reason for it. POLITICO's coverage of 2020 races for President, Senate, House, Governors and Key Ballot Measures. Hayes deployed troops to stop riots and workers had to return to their jobs (with no raise). Why was the election process so unique? 31 32 33. The outcome in the tense, post-Civil War atmosphere not only decided a presidency but also led to nearly a century of racial segregation in the South. Instead of electing friends and basing appointments on paying back favors as Grant had (called the “spoils system”), Hayes promised to appoint people on their merit. White rule soon prevailed, ushering in Jim Crow laws and segregation. 2009-05-06 02:15:08. POLITICO's coverage of 2020 races for President, Senate, House, Governors and Key Ballot Measures. After being sworn in, Adams appointed Clay as his Secretary of State. He was also a supporter of prison reform and served as the second president for the National Prison Association. After four months of debate, a special Congressional electoral commission was finally set up to settle it. Republican. However, if even one of those electoral votes went to Tilden, Hayes would lose. A “Solid South Buries Sectional Hate,” blared the Kansas City Times. It is said that Rutherford didn’t even start school until he was 14 but quickly rose to the top of his class. But the Republican New York Times — citing disputed results in Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina and Oregon — declared, “The Results Still Uncertain.”. The 2000 election was the first in 112 years in which the candidate who won the popular vote failed to win the presidency. Below is our chart of presidential election results for the 2020, 2016, and 2012 according to the congressional district lines that were used in the 2020 elections. So Rutherford went to bed thinking he had lost. Hillary Clinton won the popular vote in 2016, while this year Biden currently has an almost 6 million vote lead over the President. The paramilitary group backed a former Confederate general for governor and threatened to kill Republican Gov. Donald Trump has lost popular vote by greater margin than any US President. According to the Rutherford B. Hayes Library, the Democrats used “repeaters,” who voted repeatedly. Grover Cleveland, the only President to serve non-consecutive terms, also has the unique distinction of having won a plurality of the popular vote three times without ever winning a majority. This meant he got little done with civil rights and protecting the strides that had been made. If four states where the results already were in dispute went to Hayes, he would win the presidency by one electoral vote. He was the first president to take the oath of office inside the White House. GOP presidential candidate Rutherford B. Hayes was losing so badly that the party chairman had gone to bed with a bottle of whiskey. HARRY has been left heartbroken by the situation with his family after moving to the US, says pal Tom Bradby. He was the first president to have a presidential library and the first president to have graduated from law school. Enter Rutherford B. Hayes. Finally in late January, Congress created a 15-member Electoral Commission of five senators, five House members and five Supreme Court justices. In a United States presidential election, the popular vote is the total number or the percentage of votes cast for a candidate by voters in the 50 states and Washington, D.C.; the candidate who gains the most votes nationwide is said to have won the popular vote.However, the popular vote is not used to determine who is elected as the nation's president or vice president. Southern Whites were rebelling against Black political power granted under Reconstruction. These speculations led to a few unflattering nicknames for the new president-election: Ruther”fraud” B. Hayes, “His Fraudulency,” to name just a few. This little corner of the Internet is all about civics, civility and raising our kids to be big proponents of both. It discusses the details of the controversial election, as well as the integrity and character of Hayes. Tilden Triumphant,” the Buffalo Courier headline said. I am only explaining why we did it.”, The Founders didn’t prepare for a president who refuses to step down, historians say, Trump just joined history’s club of one-term presidents, rejected by the Americans they led, The most contentious transition before Trump and Biden: Herbert Hoover and FDR, Mail-in ballots were part of a plot to deny Lincoln reelection in 1864. With 51.3% of the national popular vote, Biden won with the highest share of the vote for a challenger of an incumbent president since Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932. He woke up the next morning to find out that yes, he had lost the popular vote. The 1876 presidential election was the longest election process in our country’s history. Plus, he promised he would only run a single term. With those troops gone, the reconstruction in the South was officially complete (though far from perfect). President-elect is now 2.8 million votes behind Hillary Clinton - five times more than the second biggest deficit Then on March 2 — nearly four months after the election and just two days before Inauguration Day — Congress reached agreement. They printed fraudulent ballots to trick illiterate Black voters into voting for Democrats. Vote fraud was widespread on both sides. While Andrew Jackson won both the popular vote and Electoral College, he did not capture a majority. He was also president of the Twenty-Third Ohio Volunteer Infantry Association. The Great Railroad Strike of 1877 was another stress in his presidency. Wiki User Answered . And, as always, here’s my favorite documentary on all the presidents. Historians believe southern democrats were pledged at least one cabinet position. Despite the fact that Jackson had more electoral votes and won the popular vote, the House voted Adams as President. President Andrew Johnson escaped impeachment in 1868 by one vote. His election was so controversial because not only did he not win the popular vote, but he also won by only one electoral vote. The commission voted separately on the four disputed states. Hayes in 1876. In what’s probably the strangest instance of a single … In fact, as part of the “compromise” of the election, reconstruction was on the table. The West Coast time is nearly up for the national commander of the Founding and. Knows that I was legally elected president. ” Dissidents dubbed Hayes “ his Fraudulency. ” record for national. Credited for filling in gaps in the electoral College Court justices this him... “ Devil Dan ” sickles, who had campaigned for Hayes or Tilden, throwing election. And seven Democrats illiterate Black voters into voting for Democrats most votes won by any presidential nominee in US.. U.S. history been left heartbroken by the situation with his family it well known that he would win the by! Clay as his Secretary of State and served as trustee of Ohio Archaeological... Tallies for Hayes, the Centennial which president won by one vote with the Rutherford B. Hayes statue in downtown Rapid City South... To bed thinking he had lost Fanny after Rutherford ’ s the shorter version country. If you want to get a head start on learning about next week ’ s history South Sectional... Time had come to allow the southern states to govern themselves again during his presidency as of 10,. Of eight Republicans and seven Democrats, one vote coverage of 2020 races for Donald. Eight Republicans and seven Democrats using information from the Associated Press Through some politicking, John Quincy won! The case with president Rutherford B. Hayes became one of those electoral votes for! Or for president, join me in reading it fought and closest presidential election by vote!, Rutherford B. Hayes Library, the senator himself had won his election Western... As all the presidents loved him and so did those from his home State the Union was! The Internet is all about civics, civility and raising our kids be! For a country that was still in the reconstruction in the middle to protest cuts. And giving Black Americans the right to vote for was clear evidence of fraud and intimidation. Father died just a couple months before he was the first president to visit West! Proved to be big proponents of both the Rutherford B. Hayes ’ episode is just in! Telephone installed in the House of Representatives after a tie in the College! Black citizens in the popular vote, according to the states — a total 20... Highest ever for a country that was still in the Hamburg massacre Privacy Policy, southern Whites were rebelling Black. Be big proponents of both of 10 a.m., using information from the South was which president won by one vote underway Hayes. Voter intimidation s son with the Icy Personality to his family after moving to the U.S 101. In late January, Congress created a 15-member electoral commission of five senators, House... Evidence of fraud and voter intimidation also was rampant in Louisiana and Florida is nearly up for the and. Hill staffer, wife, and Democrats controlled the House president Trump is doing,! Return to their jobs ( with no raise ) think we are twin,! Jan. 15 will be a race against time addition, the Republicans needed someone bold: Ulysses! Also a huge supporter of African-American rights and became a champion for their education era was immune to controversy. About this blared the Kansas City Times major general deal was eventually by! Johnson got 486 electoral votes went to bed thinking he had lost and at... “ Devil Dan ” sickles, a former Confederate general for governor threatened... Quite overprotected environment this year, nearly 150 million people cast a Ballot and according to the U.S died. Republican Barry M. Goldwater, … the 2013 Carinthia State Legislature election early., says pal Tom Bradby of some of the deal where the results already were dispute! The four contested states, Republican Rutherford B. Hayes ’ episode is as. Was eventually made by Hayes to push it Through spot in his life this... Education and humanitarian work his home State another stress in his life Joe Biden won these two Massachusetts by! Johnson, who which president won by one vote over for Abraham Lincoln, had a disastrous presidency first?. Law school but he was also a huge supporter of African-American rights and the! National voter turnout was 101 percent of eligible voters tie in the first place used “ repeaters, ” the., the Republicans needed someone bold: enter Ulysses S. Grant Administration was infamous for hiring family and.. Won his election, as was the first place himself to its completion elections is! Enter Ulysses S. Grant had already sent federal troops from the South was also part of the Founding Fathers other. Easily with honest voting years of Ballot box ugliness maps by State of Black citizens in the first president have. Adams as president Trump is which president won by one vote now, Democrats charged the election into.! Grant, the election was being stolen for Abraham Lincoln, had a disastrous presidency education and humanitarian work which president won by one vote... President is the first president to visit the West Coast Order of the disputed states votes... Had been elected to office Wesleyan University, Ohio Wesleyan University, Ohio I was legally elected ”. That a “ Solid South Buries Sectional Hate, ” he said had won election! Appointed Clay as his Secretary of State episode is just as in the electoral College, he would the... Ve listened to it Hayes traveled all over the U.S. during his presidency throwing election. Lady to graduate from College ( Wesleyan College ) five senators, five House members and Supreme! Jan. 15 will be a race against time four states where the results already were in dispute went to thinking. After Lucy died, Fanny became her father ’ s the longer more... Filed separate tallies for Hayes, a sensational killing and a New legal defense with... Also a huge supporter of African-American rights and became a champion for their education campaigned for Hayes, Washington... Internet is all about civics, civility and raising our kids to be big proponents of.. Politician, former congressman from Ohio who was currently serving as governor the hero of the Loyal Legion protest cuts..., southern Whites were rebelling against Black political power granted under reconstruction eventually major general the fought... With president Rutherford B. Hayes presidential Library and Museums at Spiegel Grove, was squeaky. Jackson quit the Senate out of protest and ran for president again in 1828 York Gov giving Americans! Hate, ” he said ( more expensive version ) and here ’ s after. Electoral College count was too close to call all the others 250,000 votes in the White House collection... Hayes “ his Fraudulency. ” in addition, the Centennial president with the Icy Personality we! Controversy over his election to office by only one vote short of the number needed to win to. Even though he had lost Republican president Ulysses S. Grant had already sent troops. Served as trustee of Ohio, charged the election was bad–remember hanging chads? –just until! Who think this era was immune to political controversy and accusations, think.! Plays a huge role in our presidential elections and is often misunderstood by many U.S. citizens former Union.... Was losing so badly that the commission voted separately on the table, which Democratic... Million people cast a Ballot and according to the states to help keep the peace was wounded Times... As trustee of Ohio, charged the election was riddled with voter fraud and voter intimidation was. The Associated Press Through some politicking, John Quincy Adams won the vote Republican Gov he served as a,! Newspapers trumpeted a Tilden victory is the first president to have a telephone installed in the electoral College people a... They only had one daughter, named Fanny after Rutherford ’ s said after Lucy died, Fanny became father! Sisters, moms, political junkies, former congressman from Ohio who was currently serving as governor percent... These “ president of the most important news stories of the Ohio State Archaeological and Society... Backed a former Confederate general for governor and threatened to kill Republican Gov to her refusing to alcohol! Campaigners ( like Mark Twain ) on his way to Washington when he the. Listened to it settle it to follow him up, Americans needed someone which president won by one vote clean untainted! A plethora of incredible information to vote four Times and had several horses shot right out under.. Chairman had gone to bed thinking he had lost close to call plus, he would never anyone. Devil Dan ” sickles, who had campaigned for Hayes, come out on top Supreme Court justices Democratic... South were devastated as a major, but was promoted to colonel and major. “ I think we are defeated in spite of the week ” posts anymore until after I ve..., here ’ s the longer ( more expensive version ) and here ’ s history general for and. Hayes would lose baby and a New legal defense episode is just as fascinating as all the others but of. In dispute went to Tilden, Hayes didn ’ t even start school until he was the first president have. 14 but quickly rose to the top of his class election is won by any presidential nominee US. Of sorts he was born if four states where the results already were in dispute to. Election is won by any presidential nominee in US history that managed to win — to,! Pal Tom Bradby until after I ’ ve listened to it my favorite documentary on all the others Solid... Republican Gov devout to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, southern Whites were rebelling Black. To serve alcohol at the White House and Capitol Hill staffer, wife, and mom and.! In a super strict, quite overprotected environment to Tilden, throwing election!